2021 GM Awards Results

[Captain America]

Thanks to all participants!

Some of the vote totals are not out of 12 (the number of participants this season) due to some hitters being listed in positions they did not play during the majority of the 2020 season. Those respective votes were not counted.

2020 AL Rolaids Reliever of the Year: Pedro Beato (MIA) with 8 votes!

(Drew Storen 4 votes)

2020 NL Rolaids Relievers of the Year: Garrett Stone (LA) and Mario Hollands (COL) with 6 votes apiece!

2021 GM of the Year: Broph with 5 votes!

(Spencer 2 votes, DJMyte 2 votes, Stooolfan 2 votes)

2021 AL All-League Team:

- C Cedrick Mira (NYM; 6 votes) (Eloy Jimenez 1 vote)

- 1B Jose Abreu (WAS; 5 votes) (Justin Smoak 4 votes, Paul Goldschmidt 2 votes, Patrick Wisdom 1 vote)

- 2B Scooter Gennett (NYM; 8 votes) (Jose Altuve 3 votes, Hunter Dozier 1 vote)

- 3B Oscar Neale (PHI; 12 unanimous votes)

- SS Dee Gordon (MIA; 11 votes) (Alberto Morello 1 vote)

- 3 OF Yasiel Puig (WAS; 9 votes), Carlos Monzo (NYM; 9 votes), Andrew Bolling (MIA; 8 votes)

(Donald Countess 4 votes, Anthony Heald 3 votes, Brandon Nimmo 1 vote)

- DH/UTIL Hunter Morris (NYM; 6 votes) (Jose Abreu 5 votes, Victor Roache 1 vote)

- 3 SP Jose Fernandez (TB; 12 unanimous votes), Paul Ryan (TB; 12 unanimous votes), Matt Harvey (WAS; 8 votes)

(Patrick Corbin 1 vote, Tanner Scheppers 1 vote, Clayton Kershaw 1 vote, Lucas Giolito 1 vote)

- 2 MR/CL Pedro Beato (MIA; 11 votes), Kyle Crockett (PHI; 6 votes)

(Drew Storen 5 votes, Craig Kimbrel 1 vote, Hector Rondon 1 vote)

- 3 Honorable Mentions Jose Altuve (TOR; 8 votes), Red Wheeler (MIL; 7 votes), Justin Smoak (ATL; 4 votes)

(Lucas Giolito (WAS; 3 votes), Andrew Bolling 2 votes, Paul Goldschmidt 2 votes, Donald Countess 1 vote, Patrick Wisdom 1 vote, Mookie Betts 1 vote, Hunter Morris 1 vote, Patrick Corbin 1 vote)

2021 NL All-League Team:

- C Buster Posey (SF; 7 votes) (Ike Davis 3 votes, Mike Zunino 1 vote, James Oshiro 1 vote)

- 1B Mike Olt (LA; 6 votes) (Freddie Freeman 3 votes, Ryon Healy 2 votes, Matthew Sorrels 1 vote)

- 2B Jose Nunex (TEX; 4 votes) (Johnny Williams 3 votes, Jemile Weeks 3 votes, Adam Neth 1 vote, Robert Vasallo 1 vote)

- 3B CJ Cron (CHC; 7 votes), (Raymond DeHerrera 4 votes)

- SS Xander Bogaerts (SD; 9 votes) (Kolten Wong 2 votes, Lou Constanza 1 vote)

- 3 OF Mike Trout (OAK; 12 unanimous votes), Jorge Soler (CHC; 11 votes), Byron Buxton (CHC; 11 votes)

(Bradley Burnes 2 votes)

- DH/UTIL Josh Bell (STL; 12 unanimous votes)

- 3 SP Mark Appel (SF; 12 unanimous votes), Joe Smith (OAK; 12 unanimous votes), Lucas Sims (OAK; 9 votes)

(Willie Derrico 2 votes, Chris Sale 1 vote)

- 2 MR/CL Garrett Stone (LA; 12 votes), Mario Hollands (COL; 11 votes)

(Trevor Rosenthal 1 vote)

- 3 Honorable Mentions Bradley Burnes (COL; 8 votes), Austin Wilson (OAK; 6 votes), Raymond DeHerrera (CLE; 5 votes)

(Willie Derrico 4 votes, Lucas Sims 2 votes, CJ Cron 2 votes, Joseph Lipton 2 votes, Andrew Toles 2 votes, Mike Olt 1 vote, Jake Lamb 1 vote, Ike Davis 1 vote, Adam Duran 1 vote, Jose Nunez 1 vote)


Thanks again to everyone that contributed! Good luck in 2022!

[stooolfan]

TB was robbed in most of this

[Spencer]

Wahhh

[stooolfan]

Mar 20, 2016 1:43:07 GMT -5 Spencer said:

Wahhh

numbers dont lie 

[Birdie Sanders]

Mar 20, 2016 1:43:07 GMT -5 Spencer said:

Wahhh

[Erbes]

I guess I'm confused primarily because I never pay attention to this... buttttt shouldn't somebody like Jose Abreu be an honorable mention? He got 5 votes which is > than Smoak's 4 votes. Or what about someone like Countess who got 4 votes at his position and then 1 vote for honorable mention. The people who vote for them at a position aren't going to put the same people down for honorable mention.

Honorable mention should be the highest vote getters who miss out on their position. Not just people who get voted honorable mention.

[Erbes]

I guess Smoak is a bad example because he got 4 votes at 1B too, but you get what I'm saying.

[Erbes]

And I guess Abreu won 1B, but yeah again you know what I'm saying.

[Free Stutter!]

3 OF Mike Trout (OAK; 12 unanimous votes), Jorge Soler (CHC; 11 votes), Byron Buxton (CHC; 11 votes)

(Bradley Burnes 2 votes)

lol my 2 players didn't get a unanimous vote...

hilarious

[Broph]

GM of the year needs to be done the moment the regular season ends. I win it this year after having by far my worst regular season in what, 5 years? ITS A REGULAR SEASON AWARD GUYS....

[Broph]

Mar 20, 2016 16:49:59 GMT -5 Erbes said:

I guess I'm confused primarily because I never pay attention to this... buttttt shouldn't somebody like Jose Abreu be an honorable mention? He got 5 votes which is > than Smoak's 4 votes. Or what about someone like Countess who got 4 votes at his position and then 1 vote for honorable mention. The people who vote for them at a position aren't going to put the same people down for honorable mention.

Honorable mention should be the highest vote getters who miss out on their position. Not just people who get voted honorable mention.

Yep

[Broph]

Mar 20, 2016 16:51:24 GMT -5 Erbes said:

And I guess Abreu won 1B, but yeah again you know what I'm saying.

in this case it would mean Wilson and Derrico tie

[Broph]

and there were only 12 voters this year, not 17 as you list in the post

[Broph]

wait, why does GMOTY total to 11

[Broph]

Mar 21, 2016 6:24:48 GMT -5 Broph said:

Mar 20, 2016 16:49:59 GMT -5 Erbes said:

I guess I'm confused primarily because I never pay attention to this... buttttt shouldn't somebody like Jose Abreu be an honorable mention? He got 5 votes which is > than Smoak's 4 votes. Or what about someone like Countess who got 4 votes at his position and then 1 vote for honorable mention. The people who vote for them at a position aren't going to put the same people down for honorable mention.

Honorable mention should be the highest vote getters who miss out on their position. Not just people who get voted honorable mention.

Yep

damn, just thought of an edge case.

What if a guy is just ok, say at 2B, but 2B this year blows.

He gets 9 votes, the guy who wins the position gets 10 votes.

At 1B, SS, 3B, C, SP, there are clear cut winners, but also some very good players right after, each deserving in their own right to be HM, but, behind the clear cut winner.

these guys each split the votes, Say there are 5 guys fighting for the 3 spots. They each got 0 votes at their positions because those guys were so far and away better

there are 57 votes to split over the say, 5 candidates, all better than 2B runner up.

2 guys are clear, they each get 19 votes, that leaves 19 votes over 3 guys clearly better than 2B.

One gets 8, one gets 6, one gets 5, the guy with 8 gets left off because his position was stronger, not because he was worse than the 2B

[Broph]

Mar 21, 2016 2:39:56 GMT -5 Free Stutter! said:

3 OF Mike Trout (OAK; 12 unanimous votes), Jorge Soler (CHC; 11 votes), Byron Buxton (CHC; 11 votes)

(Bradley Burnes 2 votes)

lol my 2 players didn't get a unanimous vote...

hilarious

Who would vote for Burnes over either, awful

[Broph]

Mar 21, 2016 6:37:23 GMT -5 Broph said:

Mar 21, 2016 6:24:48 GMT -5 Broph said:

Yep

damn, just thought of an edge case.

What if a guy is just ok, say at 2B, but 2B this year blows.

He gets 9 votes, the guy who wins the position gets 10 votes.

At 1B, SS, 3B, C, SP, there are clear cut winners, but also some very good players right after, each deserving in their own right to be HM, but, behind the clear cut winner.

these guys each split the votes, Say there are 5 guys fighting for the 3 spots. They each got 0 votes at their positions because those guys were so far and away better

there are 57 votes to split over the say, 5 candidates, all better than 2B runner up.

2 guys are clear, they each get 19 votes, that leaves 19 votes over 3 guys clearly better than 2B.

One gets 8, one gets 6, one gets 5, the guy with 8 gets left off because his position was stronger, not because he was worse than the 2B

I have no idea how this would be handled, but I think the current way probably works fine

just being maybe best at your position does not guarantee you are worth being honorable mention.

[Broph]

this is an all league team though, so HM isnt really meant to be VOted on, never really paid attention (nor have I voted recently)...yeah, just give it to guys with the highest vote totals not on the list. its meant to recognize best at position, not best in league...

[Captain America]

Mar 21, 2016 6:30:49 GMT -5 Broph said:

wait, why does GMOTY total to 11

Andre chose to not vote for that because he had just re-joined